Is It Depression or Bleak Life Circumstances?

Submitted by tonyplant on October 13, 2006 - 12:40.

Have you come across the Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9)? Pfizer is terribly proud of the PHQ-9 and claims that it is an

easy to use patient questionnaire [which] is a self-administered version of the PRIME-MD diagnostic instrument for common mental disorders.

I'm met a number of carers who have been put through the PHQ-9. By anecdotal report, the lowest score to date is 20 (severe depression). Oddly enough, lots of carers have trouble falling/staying asleep, particularly if they are listening out for sounds of illness or an indication that someone is up and wandering (e.g., someone with Alzheimer's Disease). Some carers lose their appetite with anxiety and others overeat for comfort. A number are in such distressed financial straits if they've given up work to care for someone that it's not unusual for them to feel like they're failures and face a future that is so bleak that they don't want it. These questions would catch a lot of carers and their everyday circumstances.

Is it hopelessly naive to say that the PHQ-9 is describing a state of mind that would disappear in many of the affected carers if they had appropriate resources and their future didn't look quite so bleak? The GPs who administer the PHQ-9 are familiar with the circumstances of carers: do they administer anti-depressants or offer talking therapy (good luck with that waiting list), or do they look at the score and decide that it is not really indicative of depression?

Copyright 2006, Tony Plant Happystance Project

read more | add new comment | happystance | happiness | depression | carer | caregiver