star people logo
Starpeople - the website of Millennium Commission Award Winners
» visit the site


UnLtd Ideas Bank logo
UnLtd Ideas Bank - Submit, rate and discuss UK socially-oriented ideas. » visit the site


Happiness-Adjusted Age Relative To Chronological Age?


Submitted by tonyplant on June 2, 2006 - 13:48.

small figure on hill against a desolate landscape crying "it's all about me!"

There are several age-adjusted health scales used to horrify or shame us about our lifestyle choices and health. Real Age claims to calculate the biological age of your body, based on how well you maintain it. HeartAge can be used to tell a 42-year-old man that after a cardiovascular risk-adjustment, he has the heart of a 70-year-old man. There are anxiety and depression scores and quality of life scores. I'd like to propose an risk-adjusted happiness and resilience score for age. Imagine hearing, "You have the body of a 23-year-old but your lifestyle choices and general grumpiness gives you the Mind-Body score of 58-year old".

Heart driven into 2 pieces by force from a hammer: red and white colours express pain, rage and sorrowHeartAge is a novel use of the Framingham Heart Score: it has been reported in Patients' Perceptions of Cholesterol, Cardiovascular Disease Risk, and Risk Communication Strategies. A series of focus groups compared three strategies for communicating cardiovascular disease (CVD) risk. Participants saw three visual displays that represented the CVD risk for a 42-year-old man with a Framingham Heart Score that predicted a 25% probability for a CVD event within the next 10 years. A crowd chart showed 100 stick figures with 25 of them shaded to indicate the proportion predicted to have a CVD event over the next 10- years: this was contrasted with a similar chart for a same-aged man with no risk factors (1 figure shaded). Similarly, this same information was compared and contrasted in a simple bar graph. The HeartAge was also presented as a chart. But this time, a horizontal bar chart represented age. The first bar depicted the chronological age (42 years);

the second bar showed how this individual compared with the average age of a same-sex person in the Framingham Heart Study having the same 10-year probability of experiencing a CHD event. For the demonstration case, the 42-year-old had the same risk as a 70-year-old.
Analysis of the participants' reactions and responses revealed that the standard visual representations that show statistical probabilities of risk are confusing and uninspiring. However, a strategy that provides a cardiovascular risk-adjusted age calculation was
evaluated as clear, memorable, relevant, and potentially capable of motivating people to make healthful changes.
The BODE index is gaining in popularity for assessing people with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). BODE is a combination of physical and physiological indices and measurements: it can be used in conjunction with quality of life questionnaires to present a full picture of a patient's health and well-being.

An attractive smile is collaged with text fragments that read: 'I smile all the time so that no-one knows how sad or lonely I really am'

There are indices for disease and disability: there are questionnaires and scores for quality of life. There are measures of hostility and aggression that are used to identify those who may be at risk for particular symptoms and diseases. There are even short versions of a Resilience Scale. If positive psychology is to persuade people of the physical, cognitive and emotional health benefits of authentic happiness, then perhaps we need a Mind-Body Age or a Hearts and Minds Age: a risk-adjusted calculation that evaluates the harm of depression, chronic unhappiness, lack of meaning in life or poor engagement with work and studies; and evaluates the benefits of resilience, the experience of flow and engagement with work and studies, and the value of a rich social network of friends and family.

Research estimates that positive emotion is linked to greater success, better health and recovery from illness and greater longevity. When was the last time we scheduled time for cultivating pleasure, engagement and meaning in the same we that we promise ourselves to cultivate fitness by visiting the gym or a salad bar rather than a burger franchise at lunchtime? If we knew our Hearts and Minds Age, would we accept the reality of the benefits of authentic happiness and, more importantly, do something about it? If there were a Hearts and Minds Age, how many of us would be confident that it would be lower than our chronological age?

Copyright 2006, Tony Plant Happystance Project

scales | resilience | health | happystance | happiness | age


Comments

John Botifoll (not verified)

November 25, 2006 - 16:52
I believe that state of mind plays a crucial role in longevity, getting old chronologically should not weight down on any given individual and the attitude of can't do vs., will do tells the difference between mobility and kinetic energy. We can overcome any sudden crisis by getting over the fear that we are doomed because death may be near. Our mobility responds to the messages we send to our limbs via the brain. There may be a short circuit when there isn't any response to move a limb or ourselves out of ourselves and we should learn to bypass a missing message through another circuit like for instance getting over the hiccups by drinking a little bit of water and saying, jesus, drinking another little bit of wate and saying, Mary and drinking one final sip of water and saying, Joseph. Try it next time you'd have the hiccups and if it works for you as it does for me thats a clear sample of the power the brain has over your bodily functions and let your brain take over when any bodily crisis or fear assails you and you'll find that your body will respond.


Comments

Anonymous (not verified)

June 16, 2006 - 02:47

Tony- that is becaus the guy running the program said that happiness is the most important thing kids can learn in school. 

 QUOTE:

Anthony Seldon, the headmaster of Wellington College, explained: "We have been focusing too much on academics and missing something far more important.

"To me, the most important job of any school is to turn out young men and women who are happy and secure - more important than the latest bulletin from the Department for Education about whatever."http://www.timesonline.co.uk/article/0,,2-2138389,00.html

 

Keith- if you and your wife really do THIS:

My wife and I will occasionally ask one another, "How's your Quality of Life Index these days?" and we will give each other time to verbalize what's working and not working in our daily lives....................

 ...then wow how enlighteningly dull.  How does that even come up in conversation?  Where is the honesty in that statement?  Your QOLI??

How are you doing?  How are you feeling?  Man- you look unhappy- what is wrong?  That is how people who are not into bureaucratic speak talk.  Maybe it is different where I am from, but I honestly think that if my husband or wife ever said that to me I would either cry because it sounded so clinical, or laugh because I thought s/he was playing a joke. 

Sorry if I am being judgemental, and I am not trying to be, and I do hope that you all are much more passionate while not talking about your QOLI than you sounded here. 

QOLI also includes a sense of humour!!!

 



Comments

tonyplant

June 16, 2006 - 16:59

Hi, I know that Seldon was quoted as talking about happiness - from what I know, I strongly suspect that this was substituted for 'resilience' as happiness is thought to be a more familiar term. To be honest, from listening to the teachers and educators ranting about the vast numbers of bulletins from the DoE, I think most of them would consider piano lessons to gerbils as being more relevant or important.

Wellington has excellent academic results - I expect these to continue, I would also expect the school children to pick up some very useful skills that will contribute to their well-being and success in later life.

Tony Happystance



Comments

Keith (not verified)

June 3, 2006 - 18:48
Hi. I so very much appreciate your (happy) stance and how you present options for increasing longevity and quality of life and health. My wife and I will occasionally ask one another, "How's your Quality of Life Index these days?" and we will give each other time to verbalize what's working and not working in our daily lives. Gratitude and acceptance go far to increasing that index, and I love how you remind us all so diligently. 


Comments

tonyplant

June 4, 2006 - 12:19

Hi Keith,

As you know, I just so admire the resilience of people who can work with chronic illness and addiction in the way that you do. I don't think that happiness is a panacea for all ills, but I strongly believe that resilience is a powerful force that we can harness for our own good and for that of others.

A school in the UK is introducing weekly one hour sessions in what I would call resilience, but some sections of the media are deriding as happiness. The curriculum is all about helping young people to develop resilience to cope with everything that is happening to them and around them - I think that something like this is long overdue. However, people who aren't interested in the actual curriculum dismiss it as 'positive thinking' and happy-clappy attitudes.

Strictly speaking, the Hearts and Minds Age is really a risk-adjusted assessment of allostatic age, but that really isn't catchy enough. And it would be a seriously weird thing to ask your Best Beloved. I hope that after all your recent incidents (like the shooting of a colleague) and also giving up your teaching load, that the quality of life has improved, both for your Best Beloved and for you.

Best - Tony Happystance



Post new comment



The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.


*


About Tony Plant's blog

Blog of Tony Plant, Level 1 Award Winner for a project providing Laughter Yoga and Stress Relief workshops to carers and carer groups.

Archives

XML feed

UnLtd blogs

Other award winner's blogs

Recent blog posts

Recent comments

Tags



© UnLtd 2005
Home | Awards | Directory | Tools & Resources | About UnLtd | UnLtd Ventures | UnLtd Research | Site Map | Contact Us